LibreChat/api/server/services/MCP.spec.js

// Mock all dependencies - define mocks before imports
// Mock all dependencies
jest.mock('@librechat/data-schemas', () => ({
  logger: {
    debug: jest.fn(),
    error: jest.fn(),
    info: jest.fn(),
    warn: jest.fn(),
  },
}));

// Create mock registry instance
const mockRegistryInstance = {
  getOAuthServers: jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve(new Set())),
  getAllServerConfigs: jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve({})),
  getServerConfig: jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve(null)),
};

// Create isMCPDomainAllowed mock that can be configured per-test
const mockIsMCPDomainAllowed = jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve(true));

const mockGetAppConfig = jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve({}));

jest.mock('@librechat/api', () => {
  const actual = jest.requireActual('@librechat/api');
  return {
    ...actual,
    sendEvent: jest.fn(),
    get isMCPDomainAllowed() {
      return mockIsMCPDomainAllowed;
    },
    GenerationJobManager: {
      emitChunk: jest.fn(),
    },
  };
});

const { logger } = require('@librechat/data-schemas');
const { MCPOAuthHandler } = require('@librechat/api');
const { CacheKeys, Constants } = require('librechat-data-provider');
const D = Constants.mcp_delimiter;
const {
  createMCPTool,
  createMCPTools,
  getMCPSetupData,
  checkOAuthFlowStatus,
  getServerConnectionStatus,
  createUnavailableToolStub,
} = require('./MCP');

jest.mock('./Config', () => ({
  loadCustomConfig: jest.fn(),
  get getAppConfig() {
    return mockGetAppConfig;
  },
}));

jest.mock('~/config', () => ({
  getMCPManager: jest.fn(),
  getFlowStateManager: jest.fn(),
  getOAuthReconnectionManager: jest.fn(),
  getMCPServersRegistry: jest.fn(() => mockRegistryInstance),
}));

jest.mock('~/cache', () => ({
  getLogStores: jest.fn(),
}));

jest.mock('~/models', () => ({
  findToken: jest.fn(),
  createToken: jest.fn(),
  updateToken: jest.fn(),
}));

jest.mock('./Tools/mcp', () => ({
  reinitMCPServer: jest.fn(),
}));

jest.mock('./GraphTokenService', () => ({
  getGraphApiToken: jest.fn(),
}));

describe('tests for the new helper functions used by the MCP connection status endpoints', () => {
  let mockGetMCPManager;
  let mockGetFlowStateManager;
  let mockGetLogStores;
  let mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager;

  beforeEach(() => {
    jest.clearAllMocks();
    jest.spyOn(MCPOAuthHandler, 'generateFlowId');

    mockGetMCPManager = require('~/config').getMCPManager;
    mockGetFlowStateManager = require('~/config').getFlowStateManager;
    mockGetLogStores = require('~/cache').getLogStores;
    mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager = require('~/config').getOAuthReconnectionManager;
  });

  describe('getMCPSetupData', () => {
    const mockUserId = 'user-123';
    const mockConfig = {
      server1: { type: 'stdio' },
      server2: { type: 'http' },
    };

    beforeEach(() => {
      mockGetMCPManager.mockReturnValue({
        appConnections: { getLoaded: jest.fn(() => new Map()) },
        getUserConnections: jest.fn(() => new Map()),
      });
      mockRegistryInstance.getOAuthServers.mockResolvedValue(new Set());
      mockRegistryInstance.getAllServerConfigs.mockResolvedValue(mockConfig);
    });

    it('should successfully return MCP setup data', async () => {
      mockRegistryInstance.getAllServerConfigs.mockResolvedValue(mockConfig);

      const mockAppConnections = new Map([['server1', { status: 'connected' }]]);
      const mockUserConnections = new Map([['server2', { status: 'disconnected' }]]);
      const mockOAuthServers = new Set(['server2']);

      const mockMCPManager = {
        appConnections: { getLoaded: jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve(mockAppConnections)) },
        getUserConnections: jest.fn(() => mockUserConnections),
      };
      mockGetMCPManager.mockReturnValue(mockMCPManager);
      mockRegistryInstance.getOAuthServers.mockResolvedValue(mockOAuthServers);

      const result = await getMCPSetupData(mockUserId);

      expect(mockRegistryInstance.getAllServerConfigs).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockUserId);
      expect(mockGetMCPManager).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockUserId);
      expect(mockMCPManager.appConnections.getLoaded).toHaveBeenCalled();
      expect(mockMCPManager.getUserConnections).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockUserId);
      expect(mockRegistryInstance.getOAuthServers).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockUserId);

      expect(result).toEqual({
        mcpConfig: mockConfig,
        appConnections: mockAppConnections,
        userConnections: mockUserConnections,
        oauthServers: mockOAuthServers,
      });
    });

    it('should throw error when MCP config not found', async () => {
      mockRegistryInstance.getAllServerConfigs.mockResolvedValue(null);
      await expect(getMCPSetupData(mockUserId)).rejects.toThrow('MCP config not found');
    });

    it('should handle null values from MCP manager gracefully', async () => {
      mockRegistryInstance.getAllServerConfigs.mockResolvedValue(mockConfig);

      const mockMCPManager = {
        appConnections: { getLoaded: jest.fn(() => Promise.resolve(null)) },
        getUserConnections: jest.fn(() => null),
      };
      mockGetMCPManager.mockReturnValue(mockMCPManager);
      mockRegistryInstance.getOAuthServers.mockResolvedValue(new Set());

      const result = await getMCPSetupData(mockUserId);

      expect(result).toEqual({
        mcpConfig: mockConfig,
        appConnections: new Map(),
        userConnections: new Map(),
        oauthServers: new Set(),
      });
    });
  });

  describe('checkOAuthFlowStatus', () => {
    const mockUserId = 'user-123';
    const mockServerName = 'test-server';
    const mockFlowId = 'flow-123';

    beforeEach(() => {
      const mockFlowsCache = {};
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(),
      };

      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue(mockFlowsCache);
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      MCPOAuthHandler.generateFlowId.mockReturnValue(mockFlowId);
    });

    it('should return false flags when no flow state exists', async () => {
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => null) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(mockGetLogStores).toHaveBeenCalledWith(CacheKeys.FLOWS);
      expect(MCPOAuthHandler.generateFlowId).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockUserId, mockServerName);
      expect(mockFlowManager.getFlowState).toHaveBeenCalledWith(mockFlowId, 'mcp_oauth');
      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: false });
    });

    it('should detect failed flow when status is FAILED', async () => {
      const mockFlowState = {
        status: 'FAILED',
        createdAt: Date.now() - 60000, // 1 minute ago
        ttl: 180000,
      };
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => mockFlowState) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: true });
      expect(logger.debug).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.stringContaining('Found failed OAuth flow'),
        expect.objectContaining({
          flowId: mockFlowId,
          status: 'FAILED',
        }),
      );
    });

    it('should detect failed flow when flow has timed out', async () => {
      const mockFlowState = {
        status: 'PENDING',
        createdAt: Date.now() - 200000, // 200 seconds ago (> 180s TTL)
        ttl: 180000,
      };
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => mockFlowState) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: true });
      expect(logger.debug).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.stringContaining('Found failed OAuth flow'),
        expect.objectContaining({
          timedOut: true,
        }),
      );
    });

    it('should detect failed flow when TTL not specified and flow exceeds default TTL', async () => {
      const mockFlowState = {
        status: 'PENDING',
        createdAt: Date.now() - 200000, // 200 seconds ago (> 180s default TTL)
        // ttl not specified, should use 180000 default
      };
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => mockFlowState) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: true });
    });

    it('should detect active flow when status is PENDING and within TTL', async () => {
      const mockFlowState = {
        status: 'PENDING',
        createdAt: Date.now() - 60000, // 1 minute ago (< 180s TTL)
        ttl: 180000,
      };
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => mockFlowState) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: true, hasFailedFlow: false });
      expect(logger.debug).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.stringContaining('Found active OAuth flow'),
        expect.objectContaining({
          flowId: mockFlowId,
        }),
      );
    });

    it('should return false flags for other statuses', async () => {
      const mockFlowState = {
        status: 'COMPLETED',
        createdAt: Date.now() - 60000,
        ttl: 180000,
      };
      const mockFlowManager = { getFlowState: jest.fn(() => mockFlowState) };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: false });
    });

    it('should handle errors gracefully', async () => {
      const mockError = new Error('Flow state error');
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(() => {
          throw mockError;
        }),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);

      const result = await checkOAuthFlowStatus(mockUserId, mockServerName);

      expect(result).toEqual({ hasActiveFlow: false, hasFailedFlow: false });
      expect(logger.error).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.stringContaining('Error checking OAuth flows'),
        mockError,
      );
    });
  });

  describe('getServerConnectionStatus', () => {
    const mockUserId = 'user-123';
    const mockServerName = 'test-server';
    const mockConfig = { updatedAt: Date.now() };

    it('should return app connection state when available', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map([
        [
          mockServerName,
          {
            connectionState: 'connected',
            isStale: jest.fn(() => false),
          },
        ],
      ]);
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set();

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: false,
        connectionState: 'connected',
      });
    });

    it('should fallback to user connection state when app connection not available', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map([
        [
          mockServerName,
          {
            connectionState: 'connecting',
            isStale: jest.fn(() => false),
          },
        ],
      ]);
      const oauthServers = new Set();

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: false,
        connectionState: 'connecting',
      });
    });

    it('should default to disconnected when no connections exist', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set();

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: false,
        connectionState: 'disconnected',
      });
    });

    it('should prioritize app connection over user connection', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map([
        [
          mockServerName,
          {
            connectionState: 'connected',
            isStale: jest.fn(() => false),
          },
        ],
      ]);
      const userConnections = new Map([
        [
          mockServerName,
          {
            connectionState: 'disconnected',
            isStale: jest.fn(() => false),
          },
        ],
      ]);
      const oauthServers = new Set();

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: false,
        connectionState: 'connected',
      });
    });

    it('should indicate OAuth requirement when server is in OAuth servers set', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      // Mock OAuthReconnectionManager
      const mockOAuthReconnectionManager = {
        isReconnecting: jest.fn(() => false),
      };
      mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager.mockReturnValue(mockOAuthReconnectionManager);

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result.requiresOAuth).toBe(true);
    });

    it('should handle OAuth flow status when disconnected and requires OAuth with failed flow', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      // Mock OAuthReconnectionManager
      const mockOAuthReconnectionManager = {
        isReconnecting: jest.fn(() => false),
      };
      mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager.mockReturnValue(mockOAuthReconnectionManager);

      // Mock flow state to return failed flow
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(() => ({
          status: 'FAILED',
          createdAt: Date.now() - 60000,
          ttl: 180000,
        })),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});
      MCPOAuthHandler.generateFlowId.mockReturnValue('test-flow-id');

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: true,
        connectionState: 'error',
      });
    });

    it('should handle OAuth flow status when disconnected and requires OAuth with active flow', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      // Mock OAuthReconnectionManager
      const mockOAuthReconnectionManager = {
        isReconnecting: jest.fn(() => false),
      };
      mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager.mockReturnValue(mockOAuthReconnectionManager);

      // Mock flow state to return active flow
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(() => ({
          status: 'PENDING',
          createdAt: Date.now() - 60000, // 1 minute ago
          ttl: 180000, // 3 minutes TTL
        })),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});
      MCPOAuthHandler.generateFlowId.mockReturnValue('test-flow-id');

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: true,
        connectionState: 'connecting',
      });
    });

    it('should handle OAuth flow status when disconnected and requires OAuth with no flow', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      // Mock OAuthReconnectionManager
      const mockOAuthReconnectionManager = {
        isReconnecting: jest.fn(() => false),
      };
      mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager.mockReturnValue(mockOAuthReconnectionManager);

      // Mock flow state to return no flow
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(() => null),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});
      MCPOAuthHandler.generateFlowId.mockReturnValue('test-flow-id');

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: true,
        connectionState: 'disconnected',
      });
    });

    it('should return connecting state when OAuth server is reconnecting', async () => {
      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      // Mock OAuthReconnectionManager to return true for isReconnecting
      const mockOAuthReconnectionManager = {
        isReconnecting: jest.fn(() => true),
      };
      mockGetOAuthReconnectionManager.mockReturnValue(mockOAuthReconnectionManager);

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: true,
        connectionState: 'connecting',
      });
      expect(mockOAuthReconnectionManager.isReconnecting).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
      );
    });

    it('should not check OAuth flow status when server is connected', async () => {
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});

      const appConnections = new Map([
        [
          mockServerName,
          {
            connectionState: 'connected',
            isStale: jest.fn(() => false),
          },
        ],
      ]);
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set([mockServerName]);

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: true,
        connectionState: 'connected',
      });

      // Should not call flow manager since server is connected
      expect(mockFlowManager.getFlowState).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });

    it('should not check OAuth flow status when server does not require OAuth', async () => {
      const mockFlowManager = {
        getFlowState: jest.fn(),
      };
      mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue(mockFlowManager);
      mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});

      const appConnections = new Map();
      const userConnections = new Map();
      const oauthServers = new Set(); // Server not in OAuth servers

      const result = await getServerConnectionStatus(
        mockUserId,
        mockServerName,
        mockConfig,
        appConnections,
        userConnections,
        oauthServers,
      );

      expect(result).toEqual({
        requiresOAuth: false,
        connectionState: 'disconnected',
      });

      // Should not call flow manager since server doesn't require OAuth
      expect(mockFlowManager.getFlowState).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });
  });
});

describe('User parameter passing tests', () => {
  let mockReinitMCPServer;
  let mockGetFlowStateManager;
  let mockGetLogStores;

  beforeEach(() => {
    jest.clearAllMocks();
    mockReinitMCPServer = require('./Tools/mcp').reinitMCPServer;
    mockGetFlowStateManager = require('~/config').getFlowStateManager;
    mockGetLogStores = require('~/cache').getLogStores;

    // Setup default mocks
    mockGetLogStores.mockReturnValue({});
    mockGetFlowStateManager.mockReturnValue({
      createFlowWithHandler: jest.fn(),
      failFlow: jest.fn(),
    });

    // Reset domain validation mock to default (allow all)
    mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockReset();
    mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockResolvedValue(true);

    // Reset registry mocks
    mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockReset();
    mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue(null);

    // Reset getAppConfig mock to default (no restrictions)
    mockGetAppConfig.mockReset();
    mockGetAppConfig.mockResolvedValue({});
  });

  describe('createMCPTools', () => {
    it('should pass user parameter to reinitMCPServer when calling reconnectServer internally', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'test-user-123', name: 'Test User' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };
      const mockSignal = new AbortController().signal;

      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValue({
        tools: [{ name: 'test-tool' }],
        availableTools: {
          [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
            function: {
              description: 'Test tool',
              parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
            },
          },
        },
      });

      await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        serverName: 'test-server',
        provider: 'openai',
        signal: mockSignal,
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
      });

      // Verify reinitMCPServer was called with the user
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.objectContaining({
          user: mockUser,
          serverName: 'test-server',
        }),
      );
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer.mock.calls[0][0].user).toBe(mockUser);
    });

    it('should throw error if user is not provided', async () => {
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValue({
        tools: [],
        availableTools: {},
      });

      // Call without user should throw error
      await expect(
        createMCPTools({
          res: mockRes,
          user: undefined,
          serverName: 'test-server',
          provider: 'openai',
          userMCPAuthMap: {},
        }),
      ).rejects.toThrow("Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'id')");

      // Verify reinitMCPServer was not called due to early error
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });
  });

  describe('createMCPTool', () => {
    it('should pass user parameter to reinitMCPServer when tool not in cache', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'test-user-456', email: 'test@example.com' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };
      const mockSignal = new AbortController().signal;

      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValue({
        availableTools: {
          [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
            function: {
              description: 'Test tool',
              parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
            },
          },
        },
      });

      // Call without availableTools to trigger reinit
      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        signal: mockSignal,
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined, // Force reinit
      });

      // Verify reinitMCPServer was called with the user
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        expect.objectContaining({
          user: mockUser,
          serverName: 'test-server',
        }),
      );
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer.mock.calls[0][0].user).toBe(mockUser);
    });

    it('should not call reinitMCPServer when tool is in cache', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'test-user-789' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      const availableTools = {
        [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
          function: {
            description: 'Cached tool',
            parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
          },
        },
      };

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: availableTools,
      });

      // Verify reinitMCPServer was NOT called since tool was in cache
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });
  });

  describe('reinitMCPServer (via reconnectServer)', () => {
    it('should always receive user parameter when called from createMCPTools', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'user-001', role: 'admin' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Track all calls to reinitMCPServer
      const reinitCalls = [];
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockImplementation((params) => {
        reinitCalls.push(params);
        return Promise.resolve({
          tools: [{ name: 'tool1' }, { name: 'tool2' }],
          availableTools: {
            [`tool1${D}server1`]: { function: { description: 'Tool 1', parameters: {} } },
            [`tool2${D}server1`]: { function: { description: 'Tool 2', parameters: {} } },
          },
        });
      });

      await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        serverName: 'server1',
        provider: 'anthropic',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
      });

      // Verify all calls to reinitMCPServer had the user
      expect(reinitCalls.length).toBeGreaterThan(0);
      reinitCalls.forEach((call) => {
        expect(call.user).toBe(mockUser);
        expect(call.user.id).toBe('user-001');
      });
    });

    it('should always receive user parameter when called from createMCPTool', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'user-002', permissions: ['read', 'write'] };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Track all calls to reinitMCPServer
      const reinitCalls = [];
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockImplementation((params) => {
        reinitCalls.push(params);
        return Promise.resolve({
          availableTools: {
            [`my-tool${D}my-server`]: {
              function: { description: 'My Tool', parameters: {} },
            },
          },
        });
      });

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `my-tool${D}my-server`,
        provider: 'google',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined, // Force reinit
      });

      // Verify the call to reinitMCPServer had the user
      expect(reinitCalls.length).toBe(1);
      expect(reinitCalls[0].user).toBe(mockUser);
      expect(reinitCalls[0].user.id).toBe('user-002');
    });
  });

  describe('Runtime domain validation', () => {
    it('should skip tool creation when domain is not allowed', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'domain-test-user', role: 'user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Mock server config with URL (remote server)
      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        url: 'https://disallowed-domain.com/sse',
      });

      // Mock getAppConfig to return domain restrictions
      mockGetAppConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['allowed-domain.com'] },
      });

      // Mock domain validation to return false (domain not allowed)
      mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockResolvedValueOnce(false);

      const result = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: {
          [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
            function: {
              description: 'Test tool',
              parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
            },
          },
        },
      });

      // Should return undefined for disallowed domain
      expect(result).toBeUndefined();

      // Should not call reinitMCPServer since domain check failed
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).not.toHaveBeenCalled();

      // Verify getAppConfig was called with user role
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).toHaveBeenCalledWith({ role: 'user' });

      // Verify domain validation was called with correct parameters
      expect(mockIsMCPDomainAllowed).toHaveBeenCalledWith(
        { url: 'https://disallowed-domain.com/sse' },
        ['allowed-domain.com'],
      );
    });

    it('should allow tool creation when domain is allowed', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'domain-test-user', role: 'admin' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Mock server config with URL (remote server)
      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        url: 'https://allowed-domain.com/sse',
      });

      // Mock getAppConfig to return domain restrictions
      mockGetAppConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['allowed-domain.com'] },
      });

      // Mock domain validation to return true (domain allowed)
      mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockResolvedValueOnce(true);

      const availableTools = {
        [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
          function: {
            description: 'Test tool',
            parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
          },
        },
      };

      const result = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools,
      });

      // Should create tool successfully
      expect(result).toBeDefined();

      // Verify getAppConfig was called with user role
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).toHaveBeenCalledWith({ role: 'admin' });
    });

    it('should skip domain validation for stdio transports (no URL)', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'stdio-test-user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Mock server config without URL (stdio transport)
      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        command: 'npx',
        args: ['@modelcontextprotocol/server'],
      });

      // Mock getAppConfig (should not be called for stdio)
      mockGetAppConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['restricted-domain.com'] },
      });

      const availableTools = {
        [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
          function: {
            description: 'Test tool',
            parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
          },
        },
      };

      const result = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools,
      });

      // Should create tool successfully without domain check
      expect(result).toBeDefined();

      // Should not call getAppConfig or isMCPDomainAllowed for stdio transport (no URL)
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
      expect(mockIsMCPDomainAllowed).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });

    it('should return empty array from createMCPTools when domain is not allowed', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'domain-test-user', role: 'user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // Mock server config with URL (remote server)
      const serverConfig = { url: 'https://disallowed-domain.com/sse' };
      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue(serverConfig);

      // Mock getAppConfig to return domain restrictions
      mockGetAppConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['allowed-domain.com'] },
      });

      // Mock domain validation to return false (domain not allowed)
      mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockResolvedValueOnce(false);

      const result = await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        serverName: 'test-server',
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        config: serverConfig,
      });

      // Should return empty array for disallowed domain
      expect(result).toEqual([]);

      // Should not call reinitMCPServer since domain check failed early
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).not.toHaveBeenCalled();

      // Verify getAppConfig was called with user role
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).toHaveBeenCalledWith({ role: 'user' });
    });

    it('should use user role when fetching domain restrictions', async () => {
      const adminUser = { id: 'admin-user', role: 'admin' };
      const regularUser = { id: 'regular-user', role: 'user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        url: 'https://some-domain.com/sse',
      });

      // Mock different responses based on role
      mockGetAppConfig
        .mockResolvedValueOnce({ mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['admin-allowed.com'] } })
        .mockResolvedValueOnce({ mcpSettings: { allowedDomains: ['user-allowed.com'] } });

      mockIsMCPDomainAllowed.mockResolvedValue(true);

      const availableTools = {
        [`test-tool${D}test-server`]: {
          function: {
            description: 'Test tool',
            parameters: { type: 'object', properties: {} },
          },
        },
      };

      // Call with admin user
      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: adminUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools,
      });

      // Reset and call with regular user
      mockRegistryInstance.getServerConfig.mockResolvedValue({
        url: 'https://some-domain.com/sse',
      });

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: regularUser,
        toolKey: `test-tool${D}test-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools,
      });

      // Verify getAppConfig was called with correct roles
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).toHaveBeenNthCalledWith(1, { role: 'admin' });
      expect(mockGetAppConfig).toHaveBeenNthCalledWith(2, { role: 'user' });
    });
  });

  describe('createUnavailableToolStub', () => {
    it('should return a tool whose _call returns a valid CONTENT_AND_ARTIFACT two-tuple', async () => {
      const stub = createUnavailableToolStub('myTool', 'myServer');
      // invoke() goes through langchain's base tool, which checks responseFormat.
      // CONTENT_AND_ARTIFACT requires [content, artifact] — a bare string would throw:
      //   "Tool response format is "content_and_artifact" but the output was not a two-tuple"
      const result = await stub.invoke({});
      // If we reach here without throwing, the two-tuple format is correct.
      // invoke() returns the content portion of [content, artifact] as a string.
      expect(result).toContain('temporarily unavailable');
    });
  });

  describe('negative tool cache and throttle interaction', () => {
    it('should cache tool as missing even when throttled (cross-user dedup)', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'throttle-test-user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // First call: reconnect succeeds but tool not found
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValueOnce({
        availableTools: {},
      });

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `missing-tool${D}cache-dedup-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      // Second call within 10s for DIFFERENT tool on same server:
      // reconnect is throttled (returns null), tool is still cached as missing.
      // This is intentional: the cache acts as cross-user dedup since the
      // throttle is per-user-per-server and can't prevent N different users
      // from each triggering their own reconnect.
      const result2 = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        toolKey: `other-tool${D}cache-dedup-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      expect(result2).toBeDefined();
      expect(result2.name).toContain('other-tool');
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);
    });

    it('should prevent user B from triggering reconnect when user A already cached the tool', async () => {
      const userA = { id: 'cache-user-A' };
      const userB = { id: 'cache-user-B' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // User A: real reconnect, tool not found → cached
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValueOnce({
        availableTools: {},
      });

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: userA,
        toolKey: `shared-tool${D}cross-user-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);

      // User B requests the SAME tool within 10s.
      // The negative cache is keyed by toolKey (no user prefix), so user B
      // gets a cache hit and no reconnect fires. This is the cross-user
      // storm protection: without this, user B's unthrottled first request
      // would trigger a second reconnect to the same server.
      const result = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: userB,
        toolKey: `shared-tool${D}cross-user-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      expect(result).toBeDefined();
      expect(result.name).toContain('shared-tool');
      // reinitMCPServer still called only once — user B hit the cache
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);
    });

    it('should prevent user B from triggering reconnect for throttle-cached tools', async () => {
      const userA = { id: 'storm-user-A' };
      const userB = { id: 'storm-user-B' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // User A: real reconnect for tool-1, tool not found → cached
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValueOnce({
        availableTools: {},
      });

      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: userA,
        toolKey: `tool-1${D}storm-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      // User A: tool-2 on same server within 10s → throttled → cached from throttle
      await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: userA,
        toolKey: `tool-2${D}storm-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);

      // User B requests tool-2 — gets cache hit from the throttle-cached entry.
      // Without this caching, user B would trigger a real reconnect since
      // user B has their own throttle key and hasn't reconnected yet.
      const result = await createMCPTool({
        res: mockRes,
        user: userB,
        toolKey: `tool-2${D}storm-server`,
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
        availableTools: undefined,
      });

      expect(result).toBeDefined();
      expect(result.name).toContain('tool-2');
      // Still only 1 real reconnect — user B was protected by the cache
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);
    });
  });

  describe('createMCPTools throttle handling', () => {
    it('should return empty array with debug log when reconnect is throttled', async () => {
      const mockUser = { id: 'throttle-tools-user' };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      // First call: real reconnect
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValueOnce({
        tools: [{ name: 'tool1' }],
        availableTools: {
          [`tool1${D}throttle-tools-server`]: {
            function: { description: 'Tool 1', parameters: {} },
          },
        },
      });

      await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        serverName: 'throttle-tools-server',
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
      });

      // Second call within 10s — throttled
      const result = await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: mockUser,
        serverName: 'throttle-tools-server',
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
      });

      expect(result).toEqual([]);
      // reinitMCPServer called only once — second was throttled
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);
      // Should log at debug level (not warn) for throttled case
      expect(logger.debug).toHaveBeenCalledWith(expect.stringContaining('Reconnect throttled'));
    });
  });

  describe('User parameter integrity', () => {
    it('should preserve user object properties through the call chain', async () => {
      const complexUser = {
        id: 'complex-user',
        name: 'John Doe',
        email: 'john@example.com',
        metadata: { subscription: 'premium', settings: { theme: 'dark' } },
      };
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      let capturedUser = null;
      mockReinitMCPServer.mockImplementation((params) => {
        capturedUser = params.user;
        return Promise.resolve({
          tools: [{ name: 'test' }],
          availableTools: {
            [`test${D}server`]: { function: { description: 'Test', parameters: {} } },
          },
        });
      });

      await createMCPTools({
        res: mockRes,
        user: complexUser,
        serverName: 'server',
        provider: 'openai',
        userMCPAuthMap: {},
      });

      // Verify the complete user object was passed
      expect(capturedUser).toEqual(complexUser);
      expect(capturedUser.id).toBe('complex-user');
      expect(capturedUser.metadata.subscription).toBe('premium');
      expect(capturedUser.metadata.settings.theme).toBe('dark');
    });

    it('should throw error when user is null', async () => {
      const mockRes = { write: jest.fn(), flush: jest.fn() };

      mockReinitMCPServer.mockResolvedValue({
        tools: [],
        availableTools: {},
      });

      await expect(
        createMCPTools({
          res: mockRes,
          user: null,
          serverName: 'test-server',
          provider: 'openai',
          userMCPAuthMap: {},
        }),
      ).rejects.toThrow("Cannot read properties of null (reading 'id')");

      // Verify reinitMCPServer was not called due to early error
      expect(mockReinitMCPServer).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    });
  });
});